top of page

Simple Sourdough Bagels

Apr 16, 2025
6 min read

Updated: May 3, 2025

This sourdough bagel recipe, with its set-and-forget bulk fermentation, is great for making fresh bagels with any schedule.



If made correctly, these bagels will have:

  • A soft and light crumb with a chewy outer layer

  • The perfect crispy bottom

  • A beautiful golden colour

  • Toppings that actually stick


My favourite part about this recipe is that you can still bite into the bagels the next day without spraining your jaw!


Flour

The type of flour you use in your bagels will have an impact on the texture. Using bread flour gives bagels more of a chew, thanks to its higher protein content, whereas lower protein flours (i.e. all purpose flour) give bagels a softer and lighter texture. For this recipe, the use of all purpose flour ensures that the dough maintains the chewiness characteristic of a bagel when fresh while giving it enough tenderness to be chewable the next day. If you prefer more chewy bagels, use a 50/50 mix of all purpose and bread flour. You can also swap up to 15% of the flour in this recipe (75g) with whole wheat flour to add fibre, nutrients, or a slightly nuttier flavour without compromising the quality of the bagel.


Water

The hydration of a bagel is lower than a typical bread, which is what gives it the dense, chewy texture. This lower hydration means that you will have a dry, stiff dough, allowing for cleaner yet more effortful kneading than other breads. Avoid adding any additional water. It is expected to look tough and dry at first, but with kneading and the addition of the olive oil, it will come together nicely in time. If you are going to use a stand mixer, be sure it is fitted with a dough hook. You may need to remove it from your stand mixer and knead by hand, as a dough this tough may be too much for a typical mixer to handle.


Sugar

The brown sugar in this recipe helps to give it a nice colour and is key to keeping the inside of the bagels soft. You can substitute it with other sugars, but note that doing so will impact the colour and softness. It is possible to omit the sugar entirely, but be mindful that this will create a more dry and pale bagel. Increase the water by 15g if you are going to omit the sugar.


Sourdough starter

In true Toronto Sourdough fashion, there is no commercial yeast added to this recipe. If you choose to venture into the land of dry yeast, you're going to need to find another recipe. These bagels are leavened by sourdough and sourdough only. They are long fermented, not simply for the prebiotics, digestibility, and lower glycemic index, but for the development of character. These bagels will make you a more patient human being than their commercial yeast counterparts.


A starter fed at a ratio of either 1:2:2 or 1:3:3 is best for this recipe. Pull from your starter or use your levain when it has begun to fall. Do not use it when it is exactly 'double' or 'at it's peak' You must use it after it has peaked. It would be better to use discard/inactive/fallen starter than to use it before it has begun to fall.


Salt

The salt in this recipe helps to balance flavours, regulate fermentation, and hydrate the dough. It strengthens the gluten network, which is especially important for getting the chewiness a bagel needs. If you forget to add the salt, you'll notice your dough will be sticky and tear easily. Any finely ground salt will do (although sea salt is superior to table salt.)


Oil

Fat makes things softer. This is as true with bagels as it is with bellies. Olive oil is the fat of choice for these bagels because it's a quality fat that wont harden, which allows for a cold ferment if needed. It's also much easier to integrate into the dough. If you have a sensory issue with kneading in oil, try adding the oil to the liquids before adding the flour in. That will allow most of it to be absorbed in the formation of the shaggy dough and reduces the oily feeling when kneading.


Egg Wash

Vegan? Go ahead and swap the egg wash for a plant-based butter or olive oil wipe.

Egg-eater? Highly recommended, although not necessary. I've made these without the egg wash and I find the crust comes out more dull and hard. The egg wash gives the bagels a beautiful sheen and adds to the rubbery texture.

Heads up! You won't use up the whole egg to wash a batch of bagels. What do you do with the leftover egg? You fry it up while your bagels bake, sprinkle on some salt, and make an egg-bagel-wich that will make you 'Mmmmmm'. You're welcome.


Toppings and inclusions

My favourite toppings for these bagels are sesame seeds, poppyseeds, cinnamon sugar, and everything bagel seasoning. It's best to skip the egg wash on bagels with toppings.


Boiling

Is it necessary? Yes.

Why? Bagels don't really become bagels until they're boiled. Boiling gelatinizes the starches in the dough. This is how they get that leathery 'skin' crust. Sugar and baking soda are added to the water to help the crust get glossy and golden.

As with anything else, too much of a good thing is a bad thing. Boiling these for too long will make the crust thicker and the crumb dense. It is best to boil for about 30 seconds on each side. Place them into the boiling water tops down, flip, and then scoop out and onto a cooling rack.



Toronto Sourdough's Simple Bagels

Ingredients:

  • 500g all purpose flour (unbleached)

  • 260g water

  • 10g salt

  • 45g brown sugar

  • 125g active starter

  • 15g olive oil

  • 1 egg (for egg wash)

  • 1 TBSP baking soda (for boiling)

  • 1 TBSP sugar (for boiling)


Making the dough:

  1. Whisk together the water and starter until the mixture becomes milky. Mix in the sugar and salt until dissolved.

  2. Slowly mix in the flour until it forms a shaggy dough

  3. Add the olive oil and knead the dough in the bowl by hand. Once the oil in incorporated, move the dough onto a clean and lightly floured surface and knead for 7-10 minutes

  4. Form the dough into a tight ball and place it in a lightly oiled bowl. Cover with a bowl cover or plastic wrap let sit overnight (7-10 hours at around 80F-78F)



Shaping and the re-rise:

  1. Dump the dough out onto a lightly floured surface. Divide it into 8 - 10 pieces.

  2. Roll each piece into its own little ball. Poke a hole in the center of each ball and stretch it out to form a ring. Make the center hole larger than what you want the baked hole to be, as the center hole will shrink as the dough expands.

  3. Place each shaped bagel onto a piece of lightly floured parchment paper and cover with a damp tea towel. Dusting the parchment with flour will avoid sticking, so you don’t alter the shape of the bagels and degas them when you remove later.

  4. Let the dough sit and rise for about 2 hours, until the dough has puffed up by about 40%. This rise is important for giving the bagels a softer crumb by allowing the dough to relax - cutting it short will result in more dense bagels.


Boiling & baking the most beautiful bagels you ever did see:

  1. Preheat the oven to 425 and bring a large pot of water to a boil. As the water boils and the oven preheats, whisk an egg and set it aside

  2. Add 1 TBSP baking soda and 1 TBSP of sugar to the boiling water

  3. Gently place each bagel into the water 1 or two at a time. Flip the bagels over, allowing them to cook for 30-40 seconds on each side

  4. Use a strainer or dough hook to remove the bagels from the boiling water and place them on a cooling rack

  5. Brush each bagel with some of the beaten egg. If you wish to add toppings, like sesame seeds or everything seasoning, add them immediately after the egg 

  6. Place bagels onto a parchment lined baking sheet about an inch apart. Bake them for 25 minutes, rotating half way through to ensure they bake evenly

  7. Remove the bagels and let them cool for 25 minutes

  8. Enjoy warm with your favourite bagel toppings!


I’d love to see your beautiful bagels! Share them with me by tagging @TorontoSourdoughMama on Instagram, Facebook, or YouTube.


*Note: Sourdough baking is both an art and a science.

The art: You may need to adjust the timing and temperatures to your home and your oven. Although this recipe is tried and true - tested by my faithful and honest testers (thank you Kolaiah and Alyssa) - there may be some minor adjustments to make in terms of finding the right timing and temperature for the proofing and baking. Learning to read your dough is important. If your oven runs hot or has top coils, you may need to reduce baking temperature, lower your oven rack, or shorten baking time.

The science: You can make a few modifications with the ingredients (as outlined in the preamble ramble) and get away with it, but don't cut every corner around and expect to get the best bagel ever. Modify at your own risk.







Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page